Alternatives to Hiring a Letting Agent for Your First Let in England

If you are letting a property in England for the first time and want to avoid the 8–15% management fee that a letting agent charges, here are your realistic options: self-manage with a compliance guide, use a tenant-find-only service, join a landlord association for support, or use compliance software. Each approach trades a different amount of your time for a different level of cost savings. The best fit depends on whether you have one property or several, how confident you are navigating regulatory paperwork, and how much of the ongoing management you want to handle yourself.

Option 1: Self-Manage with a Pre-Tenancy Compliance Guide

Cost: $29 one-time (for the guide) plus the cost of safety certificates and any licensing fees Best for: Single-property landlords who want full control and the lowest ongoing cost

This is the most cost-effective route. You handle every step yourself — mortgage consent, licensing check, safety certificates, tenant selection, the tenancy agreement, deposit protection, and HMRC registration — using a compliance guide to sequence the steps and track your progress.

The Becoming a Landlord in England guide covers the full pre-tenancy workflow from consent-to-let through to move-in day, with printable worksheets for proof of compliance. Once the tenancy is set up, your ongoing duties (annual gas check, responding to repairs, managing the deposit at the end) are lighter than the initial setup.

Trade-off: You invest time upfront learning the process. The first let takes the most effort — roughly 20–30 hours spread over several weeks to work through every step. After that, renewals and year-two duties are largely repeating the same process.

Option 2: Tenant-Find-Only Service

Cost: Typically £300–£600 or one month's rent (one-time) Best for: Landlords who want help advertising, showing, and referencing tenants but will manage the property themselves afterwards

A tenant-find service handles the marketing, viewings, applicant referencing, and sometimes the tenancy agreement. You then take over for everything else: deposit protection, document delivery, ongoing repairs, and the compliance calendar.

Trade-off: You still need to understand and complete the pre-tenancy compliance steps that the tenant-find service does not cover — mortgage consent, licensing, safety certificates, Right to Rent checks, and the written key tenancy information required for a new letting. A tenant-find service finds you a tenant; it does not make you compliant.

Option 3: NRLA Membership

Cost: £95–£150/year Best for: Landlords who want a telephone helpline, template documents, and a professional community — especially if they plan to expand their portfolio

The National Residential Landlords Association (NRLA) offers compliance checklists, template tenancy agreements, a telephone advice line, and a substantial library of guidance articles. It is the industry standard resource for UK landlords.

Trade-off: The NRLA is designed for active, often multi-property landlords who need ongoing support. For a single-property accidental landlord doing one first let, the annual subscription fee exceeds the cost of a one-time compliance guide, and the sheer volume of the resource library can make it harder to find the specific workflow you need. If you plan to manage multiple properties, the membership pays for itself. If this is a one-off, it may be more than you need.

Option 4: Compliance Software

Cost: £10–£30/month (£120–£360/year) Best for: Landlords managing 3+ properties who need automated reminders, document storage, and tenant communication

Platforms like Arthur, Landlord Vision, and similar tools automate certificate expiry reminders, rent collection, maintenance tracking, and document storage. They are built for portfolio management.

Trade-off: For one property, the monthly cost exceeds the value — you are paying for multi-property infrastructure you do not use. The software also does not teach you the compliance steps; it assumes you already know what needs doing and simply reminds you when to do it.

Option 5: DIY from Free Resources

Cost: Free Best for: Landlords with time, confidence, and a systematic approach to research

Everything you need to comply is published for free across GOV.UK, your council's website, the Home Office Right to Rent portal, the deposit protection schemes, and HMRC. If you have the patience to visit eight or more separate portals, work out the correct sequence, and build your own tracking system, you can do the entire first let at zero cost beyond the statutory fees.

Trade-off: The information is scattered, unsequenced, and written for different audiences (some pages target tenants, not landlords). The risk is ordering mistakes — doing steps out of sequence or missing one entirely. Under the rules in force from 1 May 2026, civil penalties can reach £7,000 for specified breaches and £40,000 for relevant offences.

Comparison Table

Who This Is For

• First-time landlords in England exploring their options before committing to an agent or a subscription
• Accidental landlords who want to keep costs low and handle the letting themselves
• Landlords weighing whether to self-manage permanently or use an agent for the first let only
• Anyone who has been quoted 10–15% management fees and wants to know what the realistic alternatives cost

Who This Is NOT For

• Landlords who have already decided to use a fully managed letting agent — if you value the convenience and can absorb the fee, a good agent handles compliance end-to-end
• Overseas landlords who cannot practically manage a UK property themselves (though a compliance guide still helps you understand what the agent should be doing)
• Landlords dealing with a complex situation (HMO with multiple tenants, a property in disrepair, or an active dispute) who need professional management

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a tenant-find service and a compliance guide together?

Yes, and this is a common combination. The tenant-find service handles marketing, viewings, and referencing. The compliance guide covers everything the agent does not: mortgage consent, licensing, safety certificates, deposit protection, the written key tenancy information, and HMRC registration. You end up with professional tenant selection and full compliance at a fraction of the cost of fully managed service.

Is it risky to self-manage my first let?

The risk is not self-management itself — it is doing things in the wrong order or missing a step. A letting agent mitigates that risk by handling the process for you (at 8–15% of rent). A compliance guide mitigates the same risk by sequencing the steps and giving you proof-of-compliance worksheets. The outcome is the same: a lawful tenancy with a dated audit trail. The difference is cost and who does the work.

What if I start self-managing and decide it is too much?

You can appoint a letting agent at any point during the tenancy. The agent takes over management of an existing tenancy — they do not need to start from scratch. Your compliance records (safety certificates, deposit protection details, the written statement) transfer to the agent. Starting with self-management does not lock you in.

Do I still need buildings insurance and landlord cover if I self-manage?

Yes. Your standard residential buildings insurance does not cover tenants, tenant damage, or landlord liability. You need a landlord buildings insurance policy (and usually landlord contents insurance if you are letting furnished). This applies regardless of whether you use an agent or self-manage — it is a pre-tenancy compliance step, not a management choice.

See more England guides →