Bad Faith Eviction Penalty BC: The 12-Month Rent Rule

How the 12-Month Penalty Works

For a section 49 notice given on or after April 3, 2024, the landlord or purchaser who requested the notice must pay additional compensation under RTA section 51(2) equal to 12 times the monthly rent unless they prove that they accomplished the stated purpose within a reasonable period and, except for demolition, used the unit for that purpose for at least 12 months beginning within a reasonable period. For notices given before April 3, 2024, the use period is six months.

Failing either requirement can trigger the additional compensation. Re-listing the unit for rent, putting it back on the market, leaving it vacant, or simply not following through on the stated purpose can result in an award to the former tenant.

What "Extenuating Circumstances" Actually Means

The Director may excuse the landlord or purchaser from paying this compensation if extenuating circumstances prevented compliance. Policy Guideline 50 describes a fact-specific test: it asks whether it would be unreasonable and unjust to require payment, typically because circumstances could not be anticipated or were outside a reasonable owner's control.

Examples the guideline identifies as potentially extenuating include:

• Unforeseen renovation delays, difficulty getting tradespeople, a municipal stop-work order, and a close family member's health issues
• The rental unit being destroyed in a wildfire
• An employer delaying a previously approved transfer that would have allowed the landlord to move into the unit

Examples the guideline says are not likely to qualify:

• A landlord changing their mind about occupying the unit
• A purchaser deciding after taking possession that the unit does not suit their needs
• A landlord not budgeting adequately for renovations

The landlord or purchaser must prove the circumstances prevented them from accomplishing the stated purpose or using the unit as required.

The Compliance and Enforcement Unit

The Compliance and Enforcement Unit (CEU) is an independent regulatory body that can investigate bad-faith evictions without the tenant filing a complaint. When you generate a personal use or purchaser use notice through the Landlord Use Web Portal, the RTB retains your data — including birthdates and the stated intention — specifically for post-eviction audit purposes.

The CEU can impose administrative penalties up to $5,000 per contravention, per day the contravention continues. These penalties are separate from the additional compensation a tenant can claim under section 51.

How Tenants Enforce the Penalty

A former tenant who believes the landlord didn't follow through files an Application for Dispute Resolution with the RTB. The hearing examines whether the landlord or purchaser took steps to accomplish the stated purpose and used the unit for that purpose as required.

If the arbitrator awards additional compensation equal to 12 times the monthly rent and the landlord doesn't pay voluntarily, the tenant can file the RTB monetary order in the Provincial Court if the amount is within the Small Claims limit. An order above that limit can be filed in the Supreme Court. A court can enforce the order through wage garnishment or asset seizure.

Practical Implications

The additional compensation under section 51(2) is 12 times the monthly rent, on top of the one month's rent compensation due for a section 49 notice.

Before serving a personal use or purchaser use notice on or after April 3, 2024, be certain that the intended occupant will use the unit for the stated purpose for at least 12 months. If there's any chance that plans might change — a potential job transfer, a possible sale, uncertainty about the family member's commitment — the financial exposure is substantial.

If the situation is less certain, a mutual agreement (Form RTB-8) avoids the occupancy requirement entirely, because the tenancy ends by consent rather than by a landlord-initiated notice tied to a stated purpose.

For the full personal use and purchaser use workflow, including the occupancy compliance period, see the Ending a Tenancy in British Columbia guide.

See more British Columbia guides →