Check-In and Check-Out Inventory for Deposit Protection in England

The Inventory Is What Decides the Dispute

When a tenancy ends and you want to deduct from the deposit for damage, cleaning, or missing items, the scheme's adjudicator does not visit the property. They do not hear verbal testimony. They compare two documents: the check-in inventory report and the check-out inspection report. If the check-in report does not exist — or is vague, undated, or unsigned — the adjudicator has little evidence of the starting condition, making a damage claim much harder to prove.

This is not an edge case. Analysis of scheme adjudication outcomes shows that landlord claims for damages or cleaning are rejected in over 80% of cases where a dated check-in inventory is absent. Self-managing landlords who skip this step because it feels bureaucratic are effectively surrendering their right to claim against the deposit.

What a Check-In Inventory Must Include

The report should be completed on the day the tenant takes possession — before they unpack, before they move furniture in, and ideally while they are present to sign it.

Room-by-room condition record. Go through every room and record the condition of walls, floors, ceilings, windows, doors, fixtures, and fittings. Use specific language: "small scuff mark on living room wall beside door frame, approx 3cm" rather than "walls: good condition." Vague descriptions give the adjudicator nothing to compare against later.

Dated, high-resolution photographs. Photograph each room from multiple angles, plus close-ups of any existing marks, stains, or damage. Keep the date the photographs were taken clear. Take more photos than you think you need.

Appliance and fixture condition. Test every appliance (oven, hob, washing machine, boiler, extractor fan) and record whether it is working. Note the make, model, and approximate age where possible. Note meter readings.

Furnishings inventory. For furnished lets, list every item of furniture with its condition and approximate age. A five-year-old sofa has a different replacement value than a new one — the age matters for depreciation calculations.

Tenant signature. Ask the tenant to sign the inventory on the day, confirming they agree with the record. If they disagree with any entry, note their objection and have them initial the change. If they refuse to sign, record that refusal in writing and send a copy by email or recorded post.

What a Check-Out Inspection Must Cover

The check-out should happen as close to the tenant's departure date as possible — on the day they hand back keys, if practical. Use the same structure and language as the check-in report so the two documents are directly comparable.

Compare each room against the check-in record. Note any differences: new marks, damage, missing items, cleanliness. Be specific and factual — "burn mark on kitchen worktop near hob, not present at check-in" is evidence; "kitchen not left in good condition" is opinion.

Photograph the same angles. Take photos that match the check-in shots as closely as possible. Side-by-side comparison is the strongest evidence in a dispute.

Record meter readings. Compare against the check-in readings to close out utility responsibilities.

Distinguish tenant damage from fair wear and tear. Carpet pile compression after a three-year tenancy is fair wear and tear. A cigarette burn is tenant damage. Paint fading on a south-facing wall is normal ageing. Crayon marks are not. Adjudicators understand depreciation — claiming the full replacement cost of an item that was already five years old will be reduced to the remaining lifespan value.

How Adjudicators Use the Inventory in Disputes

Scheme adjudicators — at the DPS, TDS, or mydeposits — assess deduction claims using a strict evidence-based framework:

1. Baseline: The check-in inventory establishes the property's condition at the start
2. Change: The check-out report identifies any differences
3. Causation: The landlord must show the difference was caused by the tenant (not fair wear and tear or a pre-existing condition)
4. Quantum: The deduction must reflect depreciated value, not full replacement cost

A missing link weakens the claim at that step. A major weakness is step 1 — no check-in inventory means no baseline against which to compare the check-out report.

The depreciation formula adjudicators typically apply: Allowable deduction = Replacement cost × (Remaining lifespan ÷ Expected lifespan). A carpet costing £500 with a five-year expected lifespan, damaged by a stain in year four, has one year of life remaining — the maximum deduction is £100, not £500.

Professional Inventory vs DIY

Professional inventory clerks charge £80–£200 for a check-in report, depending on property size and location. That cost is borne by the landlord (the Tenant Fees Act 2019 prohibits charging the tenant for it). For a high-value deposit on a furnished property, the fee is small insurance against losing a dispute.

If you do it yourself, the quality of your documentation is what matters. A thorough, room-by-room report with dated photographs and a tenant signature will satisfy an adjudicator just as well as a professional report. The risk with DIY is cutting corners under time pressure — a rushed inventory with phone photos and no signature is worse than useless.

For the full deposit protection process — including an inventory reconciliation framework and worksheets for deductions — the Tenancy Deposit Protection guide covers every step from deposit receipt to final return.

See more England guides →