Section 11 and Section 9A: Landlord Repair Obligations in England

Two Separate Duties, One Statute

The Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 contains two implied covenants that define your repair obligations as a private landlord in England. They're often discussed together, but they operate independently — failing either one creates separate liability.

Section 11: The Repair Duty

Section 11 implies a non-excludable duty into every tenancy of a dwelling let for less than seven years. You cannot contract out of it. The duty covers:

Structure and exterior — walls, roof, foundations, chimneys, gutters, downpipes, external doors, windows, drains, and external pipes.

Installations for supply — water, gas, electricity, sanitation (basins, sinks, baths, toilets), and space heating or water heating.

The key word is "repair," not "improve." Section 11 requires you to keep these elements in the condition they were in (or should have been in) at the tenancy start. You're not required to install new systems or upgrade the property beyond its original specification — though other regulations (HHSRS, Decent Homes Standard) may push improvements through a different enforcement path.

The notice trigger. You're not liable for a repair under Section 11 until you have actual or constructive notice of the defect. The tenant reporting a leaking roof in writing starts the clock. But "constructive notice" matters too — if a reasonable landlord would have known about the defect through regular inspection, the clock may have started earlier.

Section 9A: Fitness for Human Habitation

Section 9A was inserted by the Homes (Fitness for Human Habitation) Act 2018. It implies a covenant that the property is fit for human habitation at the start of the tenancy and will remain fit throughout.

A property is deemed unfit if it is so far defective in any of these matters that it is not reasonably suitable for occupation:

• Repair
• Stability
• Freedom from damp
• Internal arrangement
• Natural lighting
• Ventilation
• Water supply
• Drainage and sanitary conveniences
• Facilities for preparation and cooking of food
• Category 1 HHSRS hazards

The practical difference from Section 11: Section 9A gives the tenant a direct route to county court to seek compensation and an order compelling repairs. They don't need the council to inspect first. If the property falls below the fitness threshold — persistent mould affecting health, for example — the tenant can bring a civil claim.

Where the Two Overlap (and Where They Don't)

A leaking roof causing damp on an internal wall engages both duties: Section 11 (exterior repair) and Section 9A (the resulting unfitness). But Section 9A reaches situations Section 11 doesn't — a property with functioning structure and installations that still fails fitness because of inadequate ventilation causing severe condensation, or a Category 1 HHSRS hazard that doesn't involve a "repair" in the traditional sense.

The Enforcement Landscape in 2026

These two statutory duties operate alongside, not instead of, the newer enforcement powers:

• HHSRS penalties — since 22 June 2026, councils can fine up to £7,000 for Category 1 hazards where removal was reasonably practicable
• Improvement notices — failure to comply is a separate offence that can attract a civil penalty up to £40,000
• Rent Repayment Orders — up to 24 months' rent for qualifying offences committed on or after 1 May 2026
• Decent Homes Standard — coming to the PRS (target 2035)
• Awaab's Law timescales — coming to the PRS (date TBD)

The practical effect: there are multiple enforcement routes for a property defect, each with different penalties and claimants. A damp issue can lead to a Section 11 breach, a Section 9A fitness claim, and HHSRS enforcement; an RRO is possible only if the landlord also commits a qualifying offence, such as failing to comply with an improvement notice.

The Decent Homes & Awaab's Law Guide maps all of these obligations into a single compliance framework, showing how each statutory duty connects to the property checks you need to make and the records you need to keep.

See more England guides →