Tenant Refuses Rent Increase in Quebec: What Landlords Must Do Next

You served a valid rent increase notice. Your tenant responded within the one-month window and refused the increase — but elected to stay. The lease still renews, but the rent stays unresolved. What you do in the next month determines whether you get the increase or lose it entirely.

The Three Response Options

Under Article 1945 of the Civil Code, a tenant receiving a rent increase notice normally has one month to choose. For a room rental, the response is due before lease expiry if that comes sooner.

1. Accept — the lease renews at the new rent
2. Refuse but stay — the lease renews at the old rent while the increase is disputed
3. Leave — the tenant gives notice of intent to vacate at lease expiry

If the tenant does not respond by the applicable deadline, silence counts as acceptance.

The critical scenario is option 2: a refusal paired with continued occupancy. This does not end the tenancy. It does not give you grounds to evict. It simply means the rent adjustment is in limbo until you take action.

Your One-Month Filing Window

Under Article 1947, you have exactly one month from receiving the tenant's refusal to file a rent-fixing application at the TAL. This is a hard deadline.

Three paths forward:

Abandon the increase. Do nothing. The lease renews at the old rent for the renewal term. Sometimes this is the right move if the increase was marginal and a hearing isn't worth the time.

Negotiate a compromise. Agree on a number between the old and proposed rent. Put the agreement in writing and both sign it. This resolves the dispute without a hearing — but don't let negotiations lull you past the one-month filing deadline. If talks are still unresolved near the end of the month, you still need to file.

File at the TAL. Submit a Demande de modification du bail / fixation de loyer through the TAL online portal or at a regional registry office. Filing fees depend on monthly rent:

Once filed, the TAL sends you the mandatory information form (RN_2026_A). You must complete it, serve a copy on the tenant, and file it with proof of service within 90 days. Miss that deadline and the file gets closed.

What the TAL Decides

The adjudicator calculates the lawful rent using the regulatory criteria — the same 3.1% base rate, tax variances, insurance adjustments, and capital expenditure amortization that you used (or should have used) when proposing the increase.

The TAL doesn't negotiate or split the difference. It runs the formula against your documented expenses. If your records are solid, the decision should land close to your proposed figure. If you're missing invoices or tax bills, the adjudicator can reject those expense entries.

The TAL hearing is strictly limited to rent adjustment. The adjudicator cannot issue eviction orders, process repossession requests, or award damages in a rent-fixing proceeding.

Common Mistakes After a Refusal

Missing the one-month window. This is the most expensive mistake. If you don't file within one month of receiving the refusal, the increase is gone for that renewal. The lease renews at the old rent by operation of law.

Assuming the refusal ends the tenancy. It doesn't. A tenant who refuses and stays is exercising a statutory right. You cannot treat this as grounds for eviction (unless the unit has a valid Section F exemption under Article 1955, where refusal does mean the tenant must leave).

Informal negotiation without a filing. Talk all you want, but file the TAL application as a safety net within the one-month period. If you reach a deal, follow the TAL's process to resolve or close the application.

The Quebec Rent Increase Guide walks through the post-refusal workflow step by step, from filing the TAL application to organizing your evidence dossier for the hearing.

See more Quebec guides →